Jason Rhodes '96
Men's Basketball
NABC/Sears NCAA Division III All-American Second Team (1996)

Lauren Turnbow '00
Women's Basketball
Women's DIII News All-American Third Team (1998 & 2000)
D3Hoops Team-of-the-Year Second Team (2000)
Women's DIII News All-American Honorable Mention (1997 & 1999)
Kodak/WBCA All-American Honorable Mention (2000)

Meg Frazier '01
Women's Basketball
NCAA DIII News All-American Honorable Mention (2000)
NCAA DIII News All-American First Team (2001)
Kodak/WBCA All-American and D3 Hoops All-American First Team (2001)

Julie Coats '06
Cross Country
NCAA Division III All-American Cross Country (2005)
NCAA Division III All-American 3,000 Meter Steeplechase (2005)

Brittney McCarthy '07
Swim and Dive
NCAA Division III All-American 1-Meter Board (2004, 2005, & 2006)
NCAA Division III All-American 3-Meter Board (2005 & 2006)

Tori Huggins '07
Women's Basketball
NCAA DIII News All-American Third Team (2007)
Kodak/WBCA All-American Honorable Mention (2007)

Jerry Maldonado '10
Track and Field
NCAA Division III All-American High Jump (2008)

Claire Mesnil '09
Women's Tennis
ITA Division III Women's All-American (2009)

Elizabeth Krug '14
Track and Field
NCAA Heptathlon National Champion (2013)
NCAA Outdoor All-American - Heptathlon (2011, 2012, 2013, & 2014)
NCAA Indoor All-American - Pentathlon (2013)

Colin Radack '14
Baseball
ABCA/Rawlings All-American Second Team (2014)
D3baseball.com All-American Third Team (2014)

Dayton Winn '17
Football
AFCA Division III All-American (2015 & 2016)

Victoria Amadi ' 17
Track and Field
NCAA Division III Indoor All-American - Triple Jump (2014, 2015, & 2017)
NCAA Division III Outdoor All-American - Triple Jump (2014)

Jared Lincoln '17
Track & Field
NCAA Division III All-American - Discus (2017)

Lauren Petrisin '18
Volleyball
AVCA All-American Honorable Mention (2016)

Sara Dyslin '18
Volleyball
AVCA All-American Third Team (2016)

Lauren Dwyer '20
Volleyball
AVCA All-American Honorable Mention (2018)

Camryn Presley '24
Beach Volleyball
AVCA DIII All-American (2022)

Kyler Greenlee '24
Beach Volleyball
AVCA DIII All-American (2023)

Abby Collier '24
Beach Volleyball
AVCA DIII All-American (2022 & 2023)

Maximus LaMendola '24
Men's Lacrosse
USILA All-American Honorable Mention (2024)

Ryan Maxwell '26
AFCA All-American First Team (2025)

Riley Brady '27
Women's Basketball
WBCA All-American Honorable Mention (2026)
D3Hoops.Com All-American Fifth Team (2026)
 

---

ACADEMIC ALL-AMERICANS

Justin Long '04
Men's Golf
Academic All-American Second Team (2004)

Jill Greshowak '06
Women's Swim and Dive
Academic All-American Third Team (2004)
Academic All-American First Team (2006)

Duncan Keegan '11
Men's Soccer
Academic All-American First Team (2011)

Tresor Mukiza '13
Men's Soccer
Academic All-American Third Team (2012)

Nick Heathscott '12
Men's Basketball
Academic All-American Third Team (2012)

Collin Radack '14
Baseball
Academic All-American Second Team (2014)

Daniel Imbro '16
Baseball
Academic All-American Third Team (2016)

Ethan Hoppe '17
Football
Academic All-American Second Team (2016)

Sara Dyslin '18
Volleyball and Women's Basketball
Academic All-American Second Team (2016) - VB
Academic All-American Second Team (2017) - WBB

Morgan Dasch '19
Women's Lacrosse
Academic All-American Third Team (2018)

Lauren Dwyer '20
Volleyball
Academic All-American Second Team (2019)